Saturday, July 16, 2011

Boycotts, Burning Man and Fernley, Nevada

From a post to the New York Burning Man List:

Here are my posts to date on the topic. The first one was originally posted to this list in full. Johnny Bonta: the Story So Far was an attempt to compile the facts we have to date. The second post was my response to a critic (and likely friend of the assailants) - The Fans Speak Out on Johnny Bonta. I've also been following the Facebook debate about spending money in Fernley and a potential Burner boycott against Fernley.

Boycotts were one of the most important weapons in the arsenal of the Civil Rights movement. (Do a little research on the Montgomery and Alabama boycotts, just for starters). Boycotts have certainly been abused - before someone else Godwins the thread, I'll bring up a certain 20th century political thinker whose followers encouraged people to boycott Jew-owned shops. They definitely cause pain to people who were not directly involved in the attack, maybe even people who are sympathetic to your cause. They can increase resentment and further divisions between communities. But they are also a very effective tool which have goaded many recalcitrant leaders into making unpopular changes.

One poster on this list mentioned his friend who lived in a nearby community but owned a business in Fernley. Because of this, said friend was unable to vote in local elections and hence had no say in what the sheriff's department. The OP sadly underestimates his friend. His friend can support to candidates who work for positive change in Fernley. He can show up at public meetings and explain how this boycott is hurting his business. He has window space for political posters and commercial space that can be used for political meetings. Vote or no vote, he is a powerful force on the ground in the community - and a boycott gives him real incentive to use that power.

You can debate whether or not a boycott is warranted in this instance. You cannot debate that boycotts have changed the course of much of 20th century American history.

2 comments:

Rachel Rosario said...

I think that it got to this point because of the incredible amount of disregard from the people who are supposed to be protecting all of us. It's a way to draw attention to what is going on. Isn't there a way for business owners who support the Bonta family and disagree with the actions of the police to show it so they are not included in the boycott?

Jeremy Turner said...

Hey, I'm the guy that created the boycott page.

I would love to hear from Lyon County business owners who have something to say about our possible boycott. I've tried a few ways of reaching out to the community, including registering with local news sites and talking about our intentions there, and writing to Lyon County officials like the Mayor. The last week I've been very busy with other things, and have only been able to steal a few minutes online here and there, but after the weekend I'll be back to moderating full-time. Hopefully as the event draws nearer, local business owners and other community members will make an effort to reach out to us.

I'm really not sure how we can open lines of communication. This has been a recurring theme in discussions on the Facebook page, but few persuasive ideas have been put forth. Please, if you have suggestions, come over to the event page and post them.

We don't want to hurt anyone's livelihood. But we feel like we have to do _something_, because a lot of us Burners are part of Lyon County's economy whether we like it or not.

I don't think I'm motivated by vindictiveness or revenge. I really want to talk to people. But all we can do is meet them halfway. I'll keep trying to open lines of communication, but at some point we have to assume that Lyon County businesspeople's silence represents a refusal to acknowledge this incident, and tacit approval of questionable police practices.

It's unfortunate, but that's the way I see it. Of course, I don't speak for everyone who's participating in the boycott (over 500 people have accepted invitations as of this posting). Each of us has his or her own motivations, and ultimately answers only to his or her own conscience.

(I should mention that many Burners, including myself, say they'll only support Tribe-affiliated businesses in Lyon County. The ethics of this is, of course, another discussion entirely.)

whatever your feelings, please come to the facebook event page and participate in the discussion. the one thing i am certain of is that we burners have power in this situation. please help us figure out what to do with it.

Post a Comment